Showing posts with label LGBTQ community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LGBTQ community. Show all posts

Monday, August 18, 2025

TOGETHER & APART


With summer Pride events winding down—Edmonton and Calgary are still slated for August—I wonder how much a parade or a dance broadens minds. I’m not thinking about straight people. Our allies have shown they love a party as much as we do. Their attendance does seem to create more of a connection just from being there. My wondering concerns all the letters that comprise that alpha-numeric combo that sometimes represents us: LGBTQQIP2SAA (or something like that—there are various versions).

 

Is the rainbow flag sufficient or are more lines, colours and shapes required? What is it about queer that fails to encompass all?

 

A passage comes to mind from Jeremy Atherton Lin’s Gay Bar (Back Bay Books, 2021):

We hear the word community all the time. Often it 

sounds like wishful thinking. Queer community is just 

as vague—just piling a confusing identity onto an 

elusive concept. Maybe community…excludes inherently…

Imagining London, I saw not one big queer coterie, but 

different people moving in different directions, entropic. 

I thought of amiable moments I shared with nurses or 

people who worked in local shops. They came to mind

clearly. A queer community I couldn’t picture.

 


Community arises from coming together and wanting to belong. Hello, Pride. But I agree with Lin that, once you define it, there will always be outsiders. Even allies don’t quite have an in. They can support queers, but as heterosexuals, they are still technically apart rather than a part. I hear some queer people bemoan how bachelorette parties have taken over drag brunch venues. I also hear disdain in their voices when they say words like heteronormative and breeders, as if all things straight people do should be shunned. There are differences between heterosexual and queer lifestyles and mentalities but, as someone who deeply felt rejected growing up, I’ve never wanted to reject in turn. I don’t twist the golden rule into, “Do unto others as they do unto you.” Hate breeding hate just feels exhausting.

 

The exclusions that get my back up even more are based on resentments and dissociations within our alpha-numeric gobbledygook designation. When I was coming out, I’d hear of gays hating lesbians and vice versa, while both groups dissed bisexuals. In the 2020s, there are people in the “community” seeking to separate themselves from trans, binary and gender-fluid identities. In turn, I’ve been dismissed by a couple of trans people who vilify my gayness and lump me in with The Patriarchy. My queerness, my outsider-ness is not outsider enough. I cannot be trans; I am just an ally. I must not take up trans space. 

 

I do get the importance of having times and places that are just for people like you. Sometimes “community” can be defined broadly as with the grander Pride events but sometimes, even during Pride Week or Month, there are gatherings just for lesbians or trans or people who identify as asexual or aromantic. People perk up when what they have in common is more specifically in common. When I meet another vegetarian (not a vegan), I literally bounce. A vegetarian? Like me! The conversation can go deeper, the connections greater. Same, no doubt when two people who are bisexual or pansexual have an opportunity to chat. 

 


Sometimes I focus too much on the divisions and all the easy ways there are to pick apart any notion of a queer community. With a glass-half-empty lens, I am brought down by the othering that pops up within and by the disdain I hear as people protect and distinguish their more specific identities. 

 

Yes, the queer “community” has its own fractures and divisions. But then what community doesn’t? Unity is so hard to achieve when we’re all independent thinkers.

 

I was away at the family cottage when Vancouver had its Pride events but maybe a big ol’ “everybody’s welcome” Pride parade might have done me some good this year. Maybe I need to zoom out more often instead of zooming in.  

Monday, July 8, 2024

LINGERING ON LABELS


We’re a product of our environments and the times in which we grew up. 

 

I grew up in an industrial city in Ontario, Canada at a time when smoking was absolutely fine—ashtrays were in every room. Tattoos were scary markings on members of motorcycle gangs and long hair on guys represented something nebulously radical or a complete lack of direction. “Retard” was a common putdown. First Nations people were reduced to caricatures. (I recall it being funny to assume a crossed-legged sitting position and raising a hand to say, “How” while jumping off a diving board.) Polack (derogatory for people who were Polish) and Newfie jokes (about people from Newfoundland) were shared without any thought of a filter. Fat people were mocked. Kids with glasses were made fun of. Same for redheads (like me). Sometimes hateful things were said about Germans, Italians, Jews, and Jehovah’s Witnesses. Basically, any group that made themselves noticed as being different and “not like the others” could be disparaged. In an oh-so-white community, race couldn’t be used to rank and hate others so people went with whatever differences stood out. 

 

Pretty much every ridiculed factor mentioned in the preceding paragraph either no longer registers as a negative or is at least no longer something to joke about in most groups. Heck, Newfoundland, formerly abbreviated as “Nfld.,” is now Newfoundland and Labrador (N.L.). Eskimos are Inuit. The Northwest Territories is now smaller after part of it became Nunavut. Change happens. We accept. We adapt.

 

I’ve often wondered if there will ever come a time when we’ll run out of groups for which to be intolerant, when John Lennon’s “Imagine” will no longer be just that, when our seeming need to sort and assert false superiority will end. 

 

Ah, but I suppose that’s a Woke dream which when you think of that as an expression is inherently paradoxical. If that’s not to be, then I wonder what group will be next on the list to mock. Who will be the new punchline? What kind of discrimination will divide society next?

 


As I wrote in last week’s blog post and in several others in recent years, the T in LGBTQ is under attack, not just among homophobes but by some who claim to be L, G or B. For them, the community has gotten too big and, I suspect, too hard to keep up with. There are tantrums and then there are people who can’t or won’t cope that drop to the ground, cross-legged, eyes closed, hands over ears. 

 

No more! Make it go away. Make it stop!

 

The world does not stop. Every generation seeks to define itself differently from the ones before. New looks, new terms and, yes, new identities—or at least newer—seek awareness. Language and the way we exist is supposed to evolve. And yet, there are always groups that fight what seems foreign. “Why can’t THEY just shut up and be more like us?” 

 

History repeats itself, even if the characters change.

 

I’ve often thought the current resistance to transgender identities and rights is a last frontier for conservatives. With gay marriage and adoption now legal, with antidiscrimination laws protecting queer people in housing and employment, homophobia is losing ground. So politicians and many citizens are going all-in to fight against trans rights. This, in turn, causes alarm for some who identify as L, G or B. Just when things seemed settled—protected, safe-ish—the pushback against trans, pronoun choices and everyone else who identifies as any other rainbow/Pride label threatens lesbians, gays and bisexuals anew. It’s like all these “new” sex and gender identities are mucking things up and, well, hello resentment.

 

Much of what people do who go out of their way to identify as “LGB” with nothing else allowed to tag along is argue about how lesbians, gays and bisexuals are DIFFERENT from all the other labels. It’s sexual identity versus gender identity, as if those lines can be so clearly delineated. To them it’s clear, long-established labels versus new gobbledygook.

 


I view their position as conveniently limited and either overtly hateful or implicitly so by means of its intentional efforts to set themselves apart. You can define yourself as narrowly as you want so it’s all about you and you don’t have to advocate for anyone else. Indeed, there has been a backlash against white cisgender gay men based on the fact many gay bars of the past glory days were dominated by them, any racial differences either shunned or fetishized. But it went beyond that. White cisgender gay men was too large a group. There was a sorting system in which “fats and femmes” were funneled out and tops were higher esteemed than bottoms. Basically, gay men, who’d been discriminated against and bullied by straight men, perpetuated the ideals of masculinity even when in spaces free of straight men. We weren’t as “free” as we purported to be when we were in our own bars. 

 


I’ve heard groans of older white gay men. They don’t like the rainbow flag getting “cluttered” with BIPOC and trans representation. No, please go back to being quiet. We see you well enough. You’re equal as long as you’re quiet. 

 

Yeah, I get why that’s a hard sell.

 

I’ll say it again: terminology will continue to change. It’s expanded the numbers in our “community” to a degree but many in younger generations who might have come out as “gay” or “lesbian” in our day are finding more specific labels better represent them. How is that a bad thing? How is being clearer about your identity an affront to those of us who went with what were the only labels available to us. A younger First Nations person today might identify as gay or lesbian but might find that 2-Spirit better embeds a cultural connotation woven into gender and sexuality. 

 


One of the first “break-off” labels was queer. When I first started hearing it, I was uncomfortable. There was something abrasive about it. It wasn’t the conventional, gym-going, bar-hopping, dance-the-night-away gays who were calling themselves queer. Instead, it seemed to be some of the outliers who didn’t fit the mold as a status gay hottie or as something passable. It seemed to be a more politically active group. People more inclined to align during the AIDS crisis with ACT UP instead of the Gay Men’s Health Crisis or AIDS Project Los Angeles.

 


“Queer” was antagonistic. It brought on negative attention. It felt like calling yourself a fag. Why embrace a term of hate and repeat it? I wanted to work within systems rather than against or around them. Of course, I grew up repressed and, despite often describing myself as hating or ignoring rules, I was a conformist. 

 

Obviously, I get what “queer” people from thirty-five years ago were doing. I thank them. I don’t see the word as having any negative association whatsoever anymore. I prefer “queer” to “gay,” which was once the all-encompassing term, often consuming lesbians when used in a broader context. Saying “gay” was less of a mouthful than always saying “gay and lesbian” and maybe tagging on “bisexual” when feeling both generous and verbose. But “gay” meant a male-oriented word was the default term in accordance with more general societal practices. In writing classes, I often wrote “he/she” when speaking of a hypothetical person but it was discouraged by instructors. When unknown, it was a he/him world. So, it’s not just the “gay community” that’s become more nuanced.

 

For many, pansexual better represents sexual orientation than the technically gender-rigid bisexuality. Take your pick. Go for it! To stick to “LGB” and put one’s head in the sand is an obstinate way of saying, “It was good enough for me so…” 

 

Somewhere in that same dinner conversation, I’d expect to also hear any or all of the following sentence starters: “In my day and time…”; “When I was young…”, and “Back in the day.” Yes, things were different. Life twenty years ago is not the same as now. Thirty years ago, perhaps more different. Fifty…you get the point. Some things come back into fashion, but other things just evolve, for better or for worse. 

 

I could go on and on. I love the label “Questioning.” Maybe it feels safer, but it also recognizes there can be an evolution or fluidity in one’s own identity in terms of sexuality and/or gender. Welcome! May some of the older members of the “community” be looked to as mentors instead of scoffers who use words like “rubbish” and “hogwash.” 

 

But trans is still the biggest sticking point. That’s the group that people who put themselves in a “LGB” compound take most offense to. So many straight people they can align with! New mixers to attend! Look at all of us. We are not alone! Maybe “LGB” is itself a nuanced offshoot. The Log Cabin Republicans of old come to mind. If you’re mainstream lesbian, gay or bisexual enough, you can fit right in. Let all the others whose sexual and gender identities are less conforming be damned. 

 

It's the age-old sort of intolerance I saw directed to other groups when I was a kid. Why do you have to be so different?

 

Not everyone fits so neatly. That’s a foundational aspect of the rainbow symbol and its permutations. I suspect that many of the people who make a conscious decision to refer to LGB instead of LGBT or LGBTQ+ fit more comfortably and, to themselves, more clearly in the L, the G or the B. Sexual orientation was the only issue. They felt 100% cisgender. That’s why they are able to so conveniently say that T is about gender so it doesn’t belong with LGB. 

 

I want to harken Dana Carvey’s Church Lady (a drag character, incidentally) and say, “Well, isn’t that special?!” 

 


For me and for many, sexuality and gender blur together. Rejection has come from both. The kinds of discrimination, the forms of hate, the official planbooks against varied sexual orientation and gender are the same. Freaks. Perverts. Out to get your children.

 

Gays and lesbians have seen this played out fully for decades. We’ve seen how being more open and fighting back changes minds. Not the minds that are too entrenched. For them, the fighting back itself is mocked. Oh, look at the gays getting all rattled up. 

 

Again, the parallels are many. Why wouldn’t we want to unite? Why wouldn’t we join what some in the “community” may see as a broadened battle? It sickens me that a gay man or a lesbian would think, Well, I got my rights. I’m done. It sickens me more that they might think, Those trans folks and those who are diddling with gender pronouns are bringing us down with them. Yes, that’s happening but the blame goes to the haters on the right. Breeding hate in our “community” is not what I ever expected when politicians and school moms went after transgender people.

 

“I’m not like them” just doesn’t work for me as a reason to hate.

 

Again, I chose to come out as gay because I had a man’s body, I was sexually attracted to men and not to women. In truth,  I struggled from my earliest years about having been born a boy. Penis? Present. But I never ever felt like a boy. I couldn’t tell anyone and there were no public figures I could look to in order to process my frustration and confusion, but I had a strong sense I’d been born with the wrong body. I felt I was a girl in every way. I felt my life would have been so much easier as a girl. There wasn’t any part of me that aligned with boy thinking, boy feeling, boy being.

 

If I were a young person today, I would identify as nonbinary or, more likely, trans. I would make the medical decision that I chose, rather than that society expected, to live trans. Hormones, yes. Surgery, I’m not so sure. I’m extremely medically squeamish. I view most medical procedures as invasive, including last week’s blood test. (Didn’t faint—though I have in the past. My anxiety was obvious to both the attendant and myself.) Any change would have had to happen when I was much younger, when my conviction was greater, when I had more time to work through a change in gender identity.

 

It’s never too late? Oh, for me it is. And I’m okay with that. I did the best I could, getting through my younger decades with what I knew at the time. I’m mulling over pronouns and whether I want to label myself as nonbinary. Those changes make more sense, but I’m still on the fence. What I do know, however, is that gender and sexuality have always been intertwined with me. The LGBTQ+ umbrella makes perfect sense to me. There are spectrums for everything. There are grays between blacks and whites. The grays actually make life clearer than the absolutism of black and white.

 


So, I’ll restate what I thought was the obvious: LGB with the T.

 

LGBTQ+. Differences within and among, yes, as it should be, but let’s work on building that community into something authentic and affirming.

 

 

 

 

 

Friday, June 18, 2021

THE TRANS GOAL: "BEING" INSTEAD OF "BEING BRAVE"


I’ve been striving to learn more about the lives of people who identify as transgender. I’m greatly concerned about conservatives in the U.S. (Republicans and many church-going folk) going back to the LGBTQ well to instill fear, indignation and repulsion in a large section of the population, especially in Red states, to rally people against a minority. 

 

Suppress them. 

Vilify them. 

Make them the enemy. 

Reject them. 

 

Many politicians thrive on uniting people through hate and ignorance. Turning trans non-issues issues into issues makes a rabid constituency froth at the mouth. Republican politicians can solidify support, manifesting in increased campaign coffers and more votes, by bringing a galvanizing issue to the forefront. To them, picking on transgender people is a no-brainer. People in general—not just Americans—have a hard time understanding and accepting differences. The more different, the more difficult. 

 


Creating fear and hating on trans people has been going on in the U.S. for a while now. Public bathrooms served as ground zero for making the public squirmy. 

 

Sample of suggestive thinking: A guy with a penis can put on a wig and walk into the women’s restroom?! Where’s my privacy? Doesn’t this pave the way for sexual offenders to walk in and rape me?

 

Politician’s thinking: Are you scared? Good! Donate to us. Vote for us. It’s the only way you can stay safe.

 

In recent years, transgender rights have gained more media attention. Much of the coverage has tried to introduce the public to actual trans people to counter fictionalized, demonized versions. Trans lives have been portrayed more on television and in movies. Celebrities, politicians and regular Joes and Jills are in public view. This is a good thing, of course, but it also ups the fear factor.

 

When people see a minority gaining ground, many feel more threatened. The urge to suppress increases. Otherwise, Life as We Know It will surely crumble. And here we are in 2021 with Trumped-up efforts to hold transgendered people down. 

 

This is a time to increase understanding of trans lives. They have the attention of some of the media at least. It is a burden. For someone who is trans, the journey to understand one’s identity is a deeply personal process that takes years, if not decades to come to terms with. There are also interpersonal issues in dealing with acceptance and rejection from friends and family. Housing and employment issues come into play as well. A trans person has plenty on their plate as it is. Going before the press to be a spokesperson, to answer questions they are tired of answering about parts of their life that other people don’t have to explain takes great fortitude. There is no obligation to do so, but some must come forward in the name of the greater cause.

 


I am writing this after getting stirred up while watching CNN’s consistently excellent “United Shades of America” with W. Kamau Bell on Sunday, June 13. This particular hour-long episode focused on Black trans women living in Dallas, Texas. It’s funny, heartbreaking, tragic, empowering, inspiring, poignant and maddening. Yes…all that. If it isn’t obvious, let me say I HIGHLY RECOMMEND watching it. (Click on the hyperlink at the beginning of this paragraph.) The people who are featured are strong, intelligent and they aren’t afraid to push back to make Kamau go beyond platitudes of acceptance. As I tweeted during the show, I love, love, love these women.

 

I want to highlight what, for me, was the most compelling moment of the “Shades of America” episode. Trans women, and even more so, trans women of color, are subject to a greater risk of violence and trauma. There is cause for a Black trans woman to be alert and guarded about where they are and who is around them. I’ve read many times that the average life expectancy in the United States for a trans woman of color is thirty-five years old. Shocking…and not true. I’m only repeating it to cite an article refuting this statistic. (The article doesn’t come from the most highly regarded source, but it is well laid out.) More accurate stats are not available, at least to my knowledge. Black trans women do live, on average, longer than that oft-stated age of thirty-five, but that doesn’t negate the fact they face significant risks in terms of violence and even murder. The statistic of a life expectancy of thirty-five is so frequently given—it reminds me of the Kinsey-based 1 in 10 figure I heard regarding gays and lesbians that always mystified me—that there comes a point when a trans woman of color believes it. In becoming my true self, I can live my life but expect it to end when I’m thirty-five.

 

Sobering.

And, for me, heartbreaking.

 

When one of the women, Pocahontas, says, “I made it to thirty-six years old,” it’s as though this is a personal victory, defying the odds. Imagine having to always be vigilant and having the shadow of an ominous, if untrue, statistic hanging over you. The media, including GLAAD, The Advocate and The Guardian have repeated this state without tracking down a primary source, perhaps in part because it’s a shocking “fact” to rally LGBT allies, but also perhaps because, given all the reports of violence, it may seem like such a plausible figure that it isn’t being fact-checked.  

 


What I took away from watching this show and listening to these women—was a greater sense that we must jump aboard the fight for trans rights. We need LGBTQ allies to act, but it needs to be expressly said that the rest of the LGBTQ community needs to get on board. They’ve been with us all along the way in seeking equal rights. In recent years, there’s been more awareness of the role of drag queens and transgendered people in fighting back against the police at Stonewall, names like Marsha Johnson, Syvia Rivera and Maria Ritter figuring into the narrative. As noted at the beginning of this post, people who identify as transgender are only the latest focus in a long history of hate and discrimination against queer people. The fight on the right has been lost with respect to marriage equality, adoption, (to some extent) HIV stigma and many areas regarding housing and employment.

 


At pro-trans rallies, there are often signs and banners that rightly declare, Trans rights are human rights. For those of us in the gay community, it’s important to personalize this more: Trans rights are LGBTQ rights. By achieving rights and protections for trans people, we strengthen acceptance and legal safeguards for ALL of us under the LGBTQ umbrella. Still, in the gay rights movement, it feels like, along the way, the transgendered community got left behind to some degree. Back in the ’90s, I remember some politically minded gay men wanting to dissociate from trans people, saying the public would get sidetracked if we were all lumped together. Trans people come off as even more different than us. To put it more bluntly, the thinking was that including transgendered people in the fight for equal rights would hold gays back. Yep, our “community” has always been more than a bit of a mess. Now is yet another time we need to come together. 

 

Let me repeat, Trans rights are LGBTQ rights.

 

Once again, I encourage you to watch the “Shades of America” episode. I hope it will inspire you and provide more insight into the struggles and successes of Black trans women. 

 

The “T” in LGBTQ is the new frontier for attack. During this month of Pride, let us learn about what it’s like to live as a transgendered person and figure out what we can do to add our voices, our money and our solidarity.